Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Black Swan....

Many readers have asked how I liked Black Swan. I liked it. Sure it was really really dark, and kinda creepy, but I felt like it was worth seeing.

What I particularly liked was that Natalie Portman, and Mila Kunis for that matter, looked like real dancers. Nothing ruins a dance themed movie quicker than when the actor hasn't studied dance. It's amateur hour and it destroys the movie for me. I read somewhere that both actresses trained 8 hours a day for their roles, for something like 8 months? It certainly paid off, and both women carried themselves like real ballerinas. Granted, I know much of the dancing was a stand-in. If you see the movie, you'll be able to tell when the stand-in is dancing, or when the shot is just of the feet, it's a professional dancer, not Natalie Portman. However, she does do a lot of dancing, and even when she is posing, standing around, or stretching, she looked authentic.

I also liked the theme and story. Yes, it was dark and creepy, but it was a great idea for a movie. The costumes and set were gorgeous! What I didn't like was that I felt like the plot had holes, almost like something was missing. Maybe the movie was heavily edited, and with that editing, parts of the plot were missing. I just felt like there was more to it, and we, the audience were missing out. I also felt like some of the prevalent themes were forced down our throats. The main theme was that dancing the role of the Swan Queen is difficult because the same dancer is playing both the "virginal" white swan, as well as the "evil" black swan. This was a challenge for the lead character in the movie, and it was driven home to the audience. The other thing I noticed was that the lead character, Nina, was written to be really naive, annoyingly so, unrealistically so. I think this is because a man wrote the character....see it for yourself and let me know your thoughts!

I would recommend this movie with caution, because its really risqué, and that isn't for everyone. Also, it's not appropriate for anyone under the age of 18.....seriously, it's racy. My friend said there was a dad with his 9 year-old daughter (probably a little ballerina) in the show she saw. He probably had a lot of explaining to do on the car ride home, and is a pretty unprepared parent, considering all the advertising for this film pump it as a psychological/sexual thriller. So go with your adult friends, not with any minors, and not with your parent....that would be awkward!

9 comments:

The enchanted home said...

Thanks for coming to my blog! Glad you liked it, means a lot coming from someone who does such a great job with her own. I agree Black Swan was good if not disturbing, but it does make you think and discuss afterwards, right? I sure did...for days! Definitely would not take a kid under 15, just my opinion.
Saw True Grit, it was great and Jeff Bridges was awesome.

Miss B. Leigh said...

I agree with you about the fact that Nina's naive character seemed unrealistic... She was sooo quiet and juvenile... She acted like a 9 year old girl herself!! (That is, until she sprouted feathers and bird-knees!!) I am such a baby... I was so creeped out by this movie... I couldn't sleep without the tv or a light on for the next two nights!! hahaha

Minnesota Girl said...

Very good and sound review. I thought it was a fantastic movie--but dark. I can't imagine taking a nine-year-old to see it. Holy inappropriate!

Carrie said...

I agree with your analysis. Especially about holes in the plot.

The Ramblings of a Thirtysomething Wife said...

I can't make up my mind about this movie and/or if I want to see it. In one preview (the one the father of the 9-year-old girl), it looks like a typical dancer movie. Then you see another preview where her eyes are all bloodshot and she pulls this small black thing from her skin...weird! Glad you liked it, though!

Preppy Little Dress said...

Glad you liked it. It's on my list of movies to watch. Thanks!!

Mugdha said...

I thought it was really well done as well! I thought her naivete was understandable. It seemed like it's supposed to be a result of being too sheltered and probably not very well-parented, seeing as her mom clearly had some of her own issues going on in the movie. I also did a review of it, so feel free to check it out!

Piper Jacquelyn said...

I have yet to see it, but am really looking forward to. I've heard nothing but good things - creepy, yes! But good! Great review, thanks for sharing!

lam said...

Thanks for your sharing!
I am operateing Wedding Dress Shops and Christian Louboutin Shoes, you may find you favorite there if you have a look. I believe everyone have a lovely babe to dress up, just like my wife. There is my shoes:
Christian Louboutin Shoes
Christian Louboutin Pumps
Wedding Dress Shops
Sorry for the bother, God bless you.